Anchor Hocking Glass Pie Plate Review

HomeReviews › Glassware & Dinnerware

Made in USA

Glassware & Dinnerware

American tempered-glass bakeware from one of the country’s last great glass furnaces.

★★★★½ 4.4 / 5 Best American Glass Bakeware

Since 1905, Anchor Hocking has made glass in Lancaster, Ohio — home to one of the last major consumer-glass furnaces still running in America. If you want oven-to-table bakeware that will outlast your recipe box, this two-pack of 9-inch tempered-glass pie plates is the everyday American standard, and it costs about what a single imported dish would.

✓ Independently reviewed✓ Manufacturing verified✓ No manufacturer influence✓ Last updated July 2026
Anchor Hocking 9-inch glass pie plate
In Short

Dependable, oven-safe American bakeware at a value price. Made in Ohio from tempered glass that handles the oven, freezer, and dishwasher, and sold as a two-pack so you always have a spare. It is plain, workaday glass — no formal warranty — but for pies, casseroles, and everyday baking, it is exactly what you want and genuinely made here.

Made in America Review Score

A Research & Evidence-Based review: scored on the same weighted six-criteria model as every product on this site. The score is calculated last, from the evidence below.

4.487 / 100
Build Quality (30%)9.0/10
Value (20%)9.0/10
Durability (20%)9.0/10
Design (10%)8.0/10
Warranty (10%)6.0/10
Made in USA (10%)10/10

Editor’s Rating: Excellent (4.4 / 5) — the American-made bakeware to beat.

This product has not been hands-on tested. Our rating is based on verified manufacturing information, published specifications, independent reporting, retailer data, and long-term reputation.

At a Glance

Best forGlass bakeware
Ideal forPies, casseroles, oven-to-table, gifts
Price (2-pack)
Made inLancaster, Ohio
MaterialTempered glass
Made in America Review Score4.4 / 5
Why Trust Us

We independently verify where each product is actually made and score it on the same weighted six-criteria model. Manufacturers do not pay for placement, and we accept no free products in exchange for coverage. See our review methodology.

Made in USA Verification

Verified: July 2026

Anchor Hocking manufactures glass in Lancaster, Ohio, and operates one of the last major furnaces still producing consumer glassware in the United States. We verified this against Anchor Hocking’s materials, the retailer listing, and the Buy American Campaign Brand Guide.

American Manufacturing

Made inLancaster, Ohio
Manufacturing statusMade in USA (tempered glass)
CompanyAnchor Hocking — making glass in Ohio since 1905
Brand GuideAnchor Hocking on Buy American Campaign →
WarrantyNo formal warranty stated (typical for glassware)

Manufacturing Confidence: High Factory location verified (Lancaster, OH) · current production verified · independent confirmation (Buy American Campaign, retailer listing) · company confirmation (anchorhocking.com).

The Anchor Hocking Story

1905Founded in Lancaster, Ohio, taking its name from the Hocking River.
20th centuryBecomes a household name in American glass bakeware, measuring cups, and storage.
TodayRuns one of the last major consumer-glass furnaces in the USA — and makes Pyrex glassware at the same Lancaster plant.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Genuinely made in Lancaster, Ohio at a historic American glass furnace
  • Tempered glass is oven-, freezer-, microwave-, and dishwasher-safe
  • Two-pack value — for a pair of 9-inch plates
  • Clear glass lets you watch crusts and casseroles brown
  • Oven-to-table looks and everyday durability

Cons

  • Plain, workaday design — not a showpiece
  • No formal breakage warranty
  • Like all glass, it can break with thermal shock or a hard drop

In Use

In the oven

Tempered glass heats evenly and browns crusts nicely, and the clear sides let you check the bottom of a pie without lifting it. It moves from freezer to oven and into the dishwasher without drama, which is why glass bakeware endures in American kitchens.

Everyday value

Buying a two-pack means one is always clean and ready, and the low price makes it painless to replace if one ever breaks — while still buying American. For the money, it is hard to do better.

Specifications

Type9-inch pie plate (2-pack)
MaterialTempered glass
Safe forOven, freezer, microwave, dishwasher
Made inLancaster, Ohio
Price

Help us keep this review accurate

Products, prices, and specifications change over time. If you have spotted an error — or if you are with Anchor Hocking and can add detail — we would appreciate your help.

Suggest a Correction
Suggest a Correction

Where to buy

These pie plates are stocked in the Buy American Campaign Store. You can also read the company’s story on Buy American Campaign.

Shop the Anchor Hocking Pie Plates

Read the Anchor Hocking Brand Guide →

How It Compares

  • Choose Anchor Hocking if you want durable oven-safe glass bakeware.
  • Choose Pyrex if you want the classic American measuring cup (made at the same Ohio plant).
  • Choose Libbey if you want everyday American drinking glasses instead.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Anchor Hocking made in the USA?

Yes — Anchor Hocking manufactures glass in Lancaster, Ohio, one of the last major consumer-glass furnaces still running in the United States.

Is Anchor Hocking glass oven safe?

Yes. This tempered glassware is rated for the oven, freezer, microwave, and dishwasher; avoid sudden extreme temperature changes.

Does Anchor Hocking make Pyrex?

American-made Pyrex glassware is produced at Anchor Hocking’s Lancaster, Ohio facility.

Does Anchor Hocking offer a warranty?

No formal breakage warranty is stated, which is typical for glassware.

Anchor Hocking vs Pyrex — what is the difference?

Both are Ohio-made tempered soda-lime glass. Anchor Hocking is best known for bakeware and storage; Pyrex for the iconic measuring cups and baking dishes.

Related Guides

Buying Guide

The Best Made-in-USA Glassware & Dinnerware Brands
Libbey, Anchor Hocking, Pyrex, and Fiesta — how to set an entirely American-made table.

Related Reviews

What owners actually say

The 9-inch pie plate carries a 4.7 from 1,666 ratings at Walmart — but look at the tail. Five percent of those are one-star, unusually visible for a five-dollar pie plate, and that is where the shattering reports live. Owners describe plates bursting ten minutes into a bake, one exploding three minutes into a preheated oven, and one that let go on the counter half an hour after coming out. Several insist there was no cold surface, no sudden swing, no prior chip. The other recurring complaint is depth: owners say the standard plate is too shallow for a double-crust apple pie and the filling boils over.

The glass explains most of it. Anchor Hocking bakeware, like modern US Pyrex, is tempered soda-lime, not borosilicate, and Consumer Reports tested both brands in the same investigation with the same result. Most shattering reports are consistent with thermal shock and are a limit of the material, not a fault in the individual dish: never set a hot dish on a wet or cold counter, never take it from freezer to oven, never use it under a broiler or on a burner, and retire any piece with a chip. The handful of reports that do not fit that pattern — a dish failing on the counter long after it cooled — point to residual stress in that particular piece, and those are genuine defects. What owners praise is real too: it browns a bottom crust better than metal, because you can watch it happen.

Should You Buy It?

Yes.

Ohio-made tempered glass that has outlasted a century of kitchen fashions, at a price that makes it an easy yes. If you bake, buy it. There is very little to say against it.

🛒 Shop This Product

The exact glass pie plate we reviewed — pressed at Anchor Hocking’s Lancaster, Ohio glassworks.

Shop Anchor Hocking in the Buy American Store →

Learn More About Anchor Hocking

Where Is Anchor Hocking Glass Made?

Where it is really made, who makes it, and how the company has held on to American manufacturing.

Read the Anchor Hocking Brand Guide →